I just watched one of the most disturbing things on TV that I’ve seen in a while. I recently discovered that one of my favorite NPR radio shows, This American Life, with Ira Glass has also become a TV show of the same name and with the same format. It’s a fascinating, well written show.
The episode I just watched has been out for a while (I download shows from iTunes since I won’t watch TV with commercials) and it has a segment shot in a hog farm. It wasn’t graphic but it did briefly highlight the problems in industrial livestock facilities that most of us in the slow foods movement are painfully aware of: the animals have such weakened immune systems that any person entering the facility must go through a full chemical decontamination process from head to toe. The animals have been bred to put on weight so quickly that at 6 months they are ready for slaughter. They live their lives in tiny little pens without access to fresh air, sunlight , grazing, the touch of their own kind or any other comfort than animals would naturally desire. These facilities are packed with so many animals that they are literally above vast lakes of excrement that end up making the residents of the areas near them sick and eventually this excrement finds its way to the ocean where it is still so toxic that it poisons the seas.
Now here’s the part that may surprise you. This isn’t what disturbed me about the episode. Oh, not to say that I am not disturbed by all that. Of course I am, but I’ve been disturbed by factory farms long before I saw this episode. I wasn’t even very disturbed by how disturbed the crew of This American Life was upon learning what conditions are like in these places. I expect most people in our culture to have very little idea of how food gets to their plate.
Here’s what disturbed me: while filming at a hog farm, the sound man for This American Life witnessed a sow giving birth. And you know what? Among all the other events he witnessed at the hog farm, among all the events I’ve described above, it was that event– the birth of some piglets–that caused him to become sick to his stomach. He threw up. & he couldn’t eat meat after that.
The one normal & life affirming thing that I saw in that entire segment is the thing that freaked him out.
Now that’s just odd to me, because the last time I checked that is how we all got here. We are all critters born of other critters.
I don’t want to pick on the man, because I really don’t know *why* he became so repulsed by witnessing such an universal event, but that fact that he said something about being grossed out at seeing those piglets “shooting out of a pig’s ass” (ass?!) leads me to think that he may be rather fundamentally psychologically disassociated from the very basics of biological functions in mammals. & I don’t think he is alone in that disassociation. In fact, I think it’s that dissociation that is a root cause of factory farms to begin with.
Now I’m not about to lecture anyone on “meat is murder.” Every animal is food for something. It’s true. Including us– no matter how much formaldehyde they fill you up with after you are dead, the microbes will eventually eat you. Whole darn planet is a cafeteria. Just the way it works.
So I am not going to say raising animals for slaughter is wrong. I’m not even going to suggest that we enter into a compact with a livestock animal that requires us to be kind and give that animal as decent a life as possible because we know that eventually we will take its life to feed our own. I’m not going to suggest that because no such compact can exist. I’m pretty sure if any animal knew it was going to be eaten it wouldn’t accede to such an agreement no matter how good a life we gave it.
No.
But I am going to say this: we should treat livestock humanely because to not do so diminishes our ability to empathize. When we do callous acts we must, of necessity, become more detached from our sense of right and wrong. We must became more detached from ourselves, lest we feel the hot uncomfortable wriggle of shame in our bellies that candid introspection would elicit. And becoming more detached we become more likely to lose more & more of our ethical bearings and empathy.
In a word- it’s harmful to *ourselves* when we treat animals as simply parts of an industrial machine.
And, I would further posit, it becomes easier for us as we become lost and numbed to treat each other as cogs in that same wheel over time.
Now, that I find disturbing.
Garden Girl on March 2nd, 2008 | File Under slow food, green, locavore | No Comments -